Merge pull request #4944 from RounakJoshi09/bug/#4497_unable-to-cherrypick-merge-commit

Bug/#4497 Unable to Cherry Pick Merge Commit Solved
This commit is contained in:
Alois Klink
2023-12-04 09:15:03 +00:00
committed by GitHub
6 changed files with 234 additions and 53 deletions

View File

@@ -811,4 +811,19 @@ gitGraph TB:
{}
);
});
it('40: should render a simple gitgraph with cherry pick merge commit', () => {
imgSnapshotTest(
`gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch feature
branch release
checkout feature
commit id: "A"
commit id: "B"
checkout main
merge feature id: "M"
checkout release
cherry-pick id: "M" parent:"B"`
);
});
});

View File

@@ -366,6 +366,8 @@ A few important rules to note here are:
1. You need to provide the `id` for an existing commit to be cherry-picked. If given commit id does not exist it will result in an error. For this, make use of the `commit id:$value` format of declaring commits. See the examples from above.
2. The given commit must not exist on the current branch. The cherry-picked commit must always be a different branch than the current branch.
3. Current branch must have at least one commit, before you can cherry-pick, otherwise it will cause an error is throw.
4. When cherry-picking a merge commit, providing a parent commit ID is mandatory. If the parent attribute is omitted or an invalid parent commit ID is provided, an error will be thrown.
5. The specified parent commit must be an immediate parent of the merge commit being cherry-picked.
Let see an example:
@@ -373,14 +375,17 @@ Let see an example:
gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch develop
branch release
commit id:"A"
checkout main
commit id:"ONE"
checkout develop
commit id:"B"
checkout main
merge develop id:"MERGE"
commit id:"TWO"
cherry-pick id:"A"
checkout release
cherry-pick id:"MERGE" parent:"B"
commit id:"THREE"
checkout develop
commit id:"C"
@@ -390,14 +395,17 @@ Let see an example:
gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch develop
branch release
commit id:"A"
checkout main
commit id:"ONE"
checkout develop
commit id:"B"
checkout main
merge develop id:"MERGE"
commit id:"TWO"
cherry-pick id:"A"
checkout release
cherry-pick id:"MERGE" parent:"B"
commit id:"THREE"
checkout develop
commit id:"C"

View File

@@ -255,11 +255,12 @@ export const merge = function (otherBranch, custom_id, override_type, custom_tag
log.debug('in mergeBranch');
};
export const cherryPick = function (sourceId, targetId, tag) {
export const cherryPick = function (sourceId, targetId, tag, parentCommitId) {
log.debug('Entering cherryPick:', sourceId, targetId, tag);
sourceId = common.sanitizeText(sourceId, getConfig());
targetId = common.sanitizeText(targetId, getConfig());
tag = common.sanitizeText(tag, getConfig());
parentCommitId = common.sanitizeText(parentCommitId, getConfig());
if (!sourceId || commits[sourceId] === undefined) {
let error = new Error(
@@ -274,20 +275,21 @@ export const cherryPick = function (sourceId, targetId, tag) {
};
throw error;
}
let sourceCommit = commits[sourceId];
let sourceCommitBranch = sourceCommit.branch;
if (sourceCommit.type === commitType.MERGE) {
if (
parentCommitId &&
!(Array.isArray(sourceCommit.parents) && sourceCommit.parents.includes(parentCommitId))
) {
let error = new Error(
'Incorrect usage of "cherryPick". Source commit should not be a merge commit'
'Invalid operation: The specified parent commit is not an immediate parent of the cherry-picked commit.'
);
throw error;
}
if (sourceCommit.type === commitType.MERGE && !parentCommitId) {
let error = new Error(
'Incorrect usage of cherry-pick: If the source commit is a merge commit, an immediate parent commit must be specified.'
);
error.hash = {
text: 'cherryPick ' + sourceId + ' ' + targetId,
token: 'cherryPick ' + sourceId + ' ' + targetId,
line: '1',
loc: { first_line: 1, last_line: 1, first_column: 1, last_column: 1 },
expected: ['cherry-pick abc'],
};
throw error;
}
if (!targetId || commits[targetId] === undefined) {
@@ -327,7 +329,11 @@ export const cherryPick = function (sourceId, targetId, tag) {
parents: [head == null ? null : head.id, sourceCommit.id],
branch: curBranch,
type: commitType.CHERRY_PICK,
tag: tag ?? 'cherry-pick:' + sourceCommit.id,
tag:
tag ??
`cherry-pick:${sourceCommit.id}${
sourceCommit.type === commitType.MERGE ? `|parent:${parentCommitId}` : ''
}`,
};
head = commit;
commits[commit.id] = commit;

View File

@@ -673,6 +673,145 @@ describe('when parsing a gitGraph', function () {
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].branch).toBe('main');
});
it('should support cherry-picking of merge commits', function () {
const str = `gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch feature
branch release
checkout feature
commit id: "A"
commit id: "B"
checkout main
merge feature id: "M"
checkout release
cherry-pick id: "M" parent:"B"
`;
parser.parse(str);
const commits = parser.yy.getCommits();
const cherryPickCommitID = Object.keys(commits)[4];
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].tag).toBe('cherry-pick:M|parent:B');
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].branch).toBe('release');
});
it('should support cherry-picking of merge commits with tag', function () {
const str = `gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch feature
branch release
checkout feature
commit id: "A"
commit id: "B"
checkout main
merge feature id: "M"
checkout release
cherry-pick id: "M" parent:"ZERO" tag: "v1.0"
`;
parser.parse(str);
const commits = parser.yy.getCommits();
const cherryPickCommitID = Object.keys(commits)[4];
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].tag).toBe('v1.0');
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].branch).toBe('release');
});
it('should support cherry-picking of merge commits with additional commit', function () {
const str = `gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch feature
branch release
checkout feature
commit id: "A"
commit id: "B"
checkout main
merge feature id: "M"
checkout release
commit id: "C"
cherry-pick id: "M" tag: "v2.1:ZERO" parent:"ZERO"
commit id: "D"
`;
parser.parse(str);
const commits = parser.yy.getCommits();
const cherryPickCommitID = Object.keys(commits)[5];
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].tag).toBe('v2.1:ZERO');
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].branch).toBe('release');
});
it('should support cherry-picking of merge commits with empty tag', function () {
const str = `gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch feature
branch release
checkout feature
commit id: "A"
commit id: "B"
checkout main
merge feature id: "M"
checkout release
commit id: "C"
cherry-pick id:"M" parent: "ZERO" tag:""
commit id: "D"
cherry-pick id:"M" tag:"" parent: "B"
`;
parser.parse(str);
const commits = parser.yy.getCommits();
const cherryPickCommitID = Object.keys(commits)[5];
const cherryPickCommitID2 = Object.keys(commits)[7];
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].tag).toBe('');
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID2].tag).toBe('');
expect(commits[cherryPickCommitID].branch).toBe('release');
});
it('should fail cherry-picking of merge commits if the parent of merge commits is not specified', function () {
expect(() =>
parser
.parse(
`gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch feature
branch release
checkout feature
commit id: "A"
commit id: "B"
checkout main
merge feature id: "M"
checkout release
commit id: "C"
cherry-pick id:"M"
`
)
.toThrow(
'Incorrect usage of cherry-pick: If the source commit is a merge commit, an immediate parent commit must be specified.'
)
);
});
it('should fail cherry-picking of merge commits when the parent provided is not an immediate parent of cherry picked commit', function () {
expect(() =>
parser
.parse(
`gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch feature
branch release
checkout feature
commit id: "A"
commit id: "B"
checkout main
merge feature id: "M"
checkout release
commit id: "C"
cherry-pick id:"M" parent: "A"
`
)
.toThrow(
'Invalid operation: The specified parent commit is not an immediate parent of the cherry-picked commit.'
)
);
});
it('should throw error when try to branch existing branch: main', function () {
const str = `gitGraph
commit

View File

@@ -39,6 +39,7 @@ branch(?=\s|$) return 'BRANCH';
"order:" return 'ORDER';
merge(?=\s|$) return 'MERGE';
cherry\-pick(?=\s|$) return 'CHERRY_PICK';
"parent:" return 'PARENT_COMMIT'
// "reset" return 'RESET';
checkout(?=\s|$) return 'CHECKOUT';
"LR" return 'DIR';
@@ -109,10 +110,17 @@ branchStatement
cherryPickStatement
: CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', undefined)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR PARENT_COMMIT STR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', undefined,$5)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR COMMIT_TAG STR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', $5)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR COMMIT_TAG EMPTYSTR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', '')}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR PARENT_COMMIT STR COMMIT_TAG STR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', $7,$5)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR COMMIT_TAG STR PARENT_COMMIT STR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', $5,$7)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_TAG STR COMMIT_ID STR {yy.cherryPick($5, '', $3)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_TAG EMPTYSTR COMMIT_ID STR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', '')}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_TAG EMPTYSTR COMMIT_ID STR {yy.cherryPick($5, '', '')}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR COMMIT_TAG EMPTYSTR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', '')}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR PARENT_COMMIT STR COMMIT_TAG EMPTYSTR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', '',$5)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_ID STR COMMIT_TAG EMPTYSTR PARENT_COMMIT STR {yy.cherryPick($3, '', '',$7)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_TAG STR COMMIT_ID STR PARENT_COMMIT STR {yy.cherryPick($5, '', $3,$7)}
| CHERRY_PICK COMMIT_TAG EMPTYSTR COMMIT_ID STR PARENT_COMMIT STR{yy.cherryPick($5, '', '',$7)}
;
mergeStatement

View File

@@ -244,6 +244,8 @@ A few important rules to note here are:
1. You need to provide the `id` for an existing commit to be cherry-picked. If given commit id does not exist it will result in an error. For this, make use of the `commit id:$value` format of declaring commits. See the examples from above.
2. The given commit must not exist on the current branch. The cherry-picked commit must always be a different branch than the current branch.
3. Current branch must have at least one commit, before you can cherry-pick, otherwise it will cause an error is throw.
4. When cherry-picking a merge commit, providing a parent commit ID is mandatory. If the parent attribute is omitted or an invalid parent commit ID is provided, an error will be thrown.
5. The specified parent commit must be an immediate parent of the merge commit being cherry-picked.
Let see an example:
@@ -251,14 +253,17 @@ Let see an example:
gitGraph
commit id: "ZERO"
branch develop
branch release
commit id:"A"
checkout main
commit id:"ONE"
checkout develop
commit id:"B"
checkout main
merge develop id:"MERGE"
commit id:"TWO"
cherry-pick id:"A"
checkout release
cherry-pick id:"MERGE" parent:"B"
commit id:"THREE"
checkout develop
commit id:"C"